logo

Info

Reviewbucket.co.uk scanned the internet for Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner Waterproof reviews.
You can find all Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner Waterproof reviews and ratings on this page.

Read the reviews.

Analysis

For Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner Waterproof, 346 customer reviews collected from 3 e-commerce sites, and the average score is 4.1.

Detailed seller stats;
Amazon has 331 customer reviews and the average score is 4.1. Go to this seller.
Ebay has 14 customer reviews and the average score is 4.2. Go to this seller.
Onbuy has 1 customer reviews and the average score is 5. Go to this seller.

Detail

Click to list all products in this category.

Similar Items

24.5.2017

Truth be told, this is a really nice eyeliner. It's very black and it's very opaque, so there's little building to do when you apply it. The tip is nice, thin, but shorter- not something I personally like but it still works well when you're trying to get that nice cat eye. The packaging is a little weird, seems like the cap is springloaded or something, but it stays on securely and doesn't come off in my bag.The formula itself is very watery, and when you're applying it to the back of you hand it does bleed and feather a little, which got me kinda worried; thankfully, this doesn't happen on the eye, and the watery consistency actually helps you get super close to the lashline and inbetween those little bits of eyelid between your lashes.I've not got sensitive eyes but I feel like this made my eyes water ever so slightly, so that might be something to keep in mind. It's one of those eyeliner formulas that dries quite glossy and "heavy", sitting on the eyelid as if it's going to crack and flake later on in the day, but it actually never does; that being said, it does tend to disappear right on the very inner corner, where your eyelid tends to be in contact with your eyeball. Not a problem for me because I don't generally like that part but it definitely comes off there. Doesn't smudge, doesn't transfer, waterproof to an extent (dab the water away, rubbing will wipe it right off) and doesn't bleed when I cry with it on. Little bit of a hassle to remove, but use some oil and you're good to go.All in all it's a real good quality eyeliner, but I definitely think you can find comparable felt liners for a whole lot less. L'oreal Super Slim in brown is my usual go to and it works just as well, granted you set it with a powder. Still a nice indulgence if you feel like spoiling yourself.
Read more..

16.3.2018

This is an excellent eyeliner I've been using for years but always bought directly from Sephora in Los Angeles. Being in London, I wasn't sure where to buy it from and was happy to see it here on Amazon. I was hesitant, however, that it might be fake but purchased it anyways. Honestly, it feels exactly the same as my old old eyeliner I'm replacing - it's fluid, it's precise, it gives you a crisp black line that makes for a great cat eye if you have a steady hand. For those that say it's not dark enough, you have to select the black option from the scroll down menu which isn't obvious when purchasing. You probably bought the charcoal colour one which the purchase is automatically set up for.So be careful of this if you do indeed want black. As for being fake, if it is, it's a very good copy. I would say it's authentic with only one difference I see between my old and this new stick - the font on the new stick is gold whereas the font on my old stick was silver. This could just be repackaging though. See photos of my old eyeliner and the new one I bought here. As for quality of product, this is an excellent eyeliner. Allow it to dry 100% before applying anymore more eye make up. For me, this is the only eyeliner I've found that doesn't give panda eyes, not even the next morning if you accidentally fall asleep with your make up on. Good luck girls!
Read more..

3.7.2019

I am a daily user of liquid eyeliner and spent a long time finding one that didn't irritate my eyes (I have dry eyes and blepharitis). I tried natural versions, but in the end it just didn't cut it. I decided instead to go for one with longevity, and after searching online I found this eyeliner which was recommended for not budging.So I used to have issues with tearing in the corners of my eyes due to eyeliner. I thought I was going to have to stop wearing it. I tried pencils, organic types, and oil types too but to no avail. This eyeliner however does not irritate my eyes at all, and it stays in place all day. It even survived spa days, it's that good (I'm very self conscious without make up!).It's a beautiful solid deep black hue,and is easy to apply. I have found the last one I bought particularly "wet" so harder to get precision, but usually the tip is very easy to create fine flicks and lines. Either way, I'd recommend this eyeliner completely for daily use. I also have no issues getting it off with an oil based makeup remover that is kind to eyes.Uodate: I just bought the alloy one and initially didn't like it as it's very light on the lid. But it's really nice as a less intense look and also stays on all day. It's actually very pretty but you can't really wear it with eyeshadow as you can't see it.
Read more..

12.10.2015

I was referred to this eyeliner after I couldn't find my previous eyeliner (Urban Decay Tattoo liner) in stock. I love the brush / felt pen nib and this is definitely better than the UD one I was using previously. I have been using this eyeliner for about 3 months ow on a daily basis, and there is still plenty of ink left.My skin in on the dry side, so I use a tinted moisturiser in place of a foundation. I have found in the past however that the moisturiser base has mean some eyeliners slip very easy and others doesn't deposit enough colour. This however gives an intense black line that dried within 10-20 seconds. The lining of my lid will stay all day, but I find if I do a winged eyeliner,the wings tend to fade and disappear after 3-4 hours. I've always had this problem with all eyeliners however, and I think this is because I tend to touch and dab my eyes quite frequently.Overall a fantastic eyeliner, easy to apply, great colour and last.
Read more..

23.9.2014

This is a wonderful eye liner. I have hooded eyes and on the whole eye liners are difficult for me as they tend to transfer on the hooded part of my lid. I have been very impressed with this product. It has a very well graduated tip that starts from super fine, allowing for very precise application. The liquid applies super easy and it is on the watery side (unlike other eyeliners of the same category which are much harder to dispense product).Once applied I keep looking down for a minute to avoid transferring until the line is set and the look lasts all day on me, thats 14-16 hrs, as I tend to put my make up on first thing in the morning and take it off last thing at night.The overall effect is glossy super black line which stays defined throughout the day and does not require retouching. I think is a stand out product and will be repurchasing in the future.
Read more..

4.11.2014

.Stila has a superb reputation in the beauty business, and the peoplexwhomuse these products also feel as strongly about them. I have not found one product that dies not live up to this reputation.This eyeliner has an easy-application, it is waterproof and stays on for most of the day. I have never had to touch it up. This is an easy-glide, quick-dry liner that stays in place with no smudges, feathering, or running. The applicator has a felt tip for easy application. It goes on smoothly.I don't wear eyeliner during the day, but do like it for night time activities. I have aging skin, and I want something that does not tug and make my under eye look wrinkly. This is the perfect eyeliner for me.Recommended.prisrob 11-03-14
Read more..

15.1.2017

Only waterproof liquid eyeliner I've found which is actually waterproof! I have very watery eyes (wind, sun, allergies etc) and eyeliner can be a nightmare. Once came in from a rather windy break duty (I'm a teacher) to be told by a student that my eyeliner was 'a bit weird'. Looked in the mirror to find it was all over my face. That was a supposedly waterproof liquid eyeliner. This one doesn't budge! The pen-style applicator makes it easy to apply. The only negative is that because it's so waterproof it doesn't want to come off - I use the type of eye makeup remover that you have to shake (with the oil layer) and it comes off a treat with that.

14.3.2019

I have tried so many eyeliners that I have lost count. All of them have ended up in the bin .....except for this Stila eyeliner. I have watery, sensitive eyes and every other 'smudgeproof' liner has run or vanished altogether after 10-15 mins. I apply this daily to the top of my lids and tightline the top lids too. It dries very quickly when I apply my eyeliner wings and doesn't budge for at least 12 hours. My only quibble is the end of the pen can get a bit straggly after multiple uses and defining the end of my wing can be a fiddle at times. But the fact that it stays put all day means it is a winner for me.

10.2.2020

I used to buy this from Stila at Boots but for some reason they stopped doing this colour so it get it from Amazon - its amazing - goes on as thin or as thick as you want as the felt tip is very fine - it is a proper brown - not to light, not too dark and not glittery or shimmery as most ones I have tried are - and it lasts all day - I use it on holiday and it does not come off with humidity or swimming and I wear it all day for work and its still on when i get get home (It goes on a 5am in the morning and comes off about 9pm in the evening). I only hope that this colour does not disappear from Amazon

4.3.2020

I have tried soo many eyeliners and this one is the best by far. It has survived many a night out, sweaty summer vacations and cry sessions and still lasts overnight if you pass out in it after. Even lasts through cleansing and face mask combos if you don’t rub. Also, perfect thin tip for those subtle on fleek looks and actually doesn’t blend too badly either if you want something more smokey. If you use it every day religiously like I do it will last over 6 months before drying out. But price is well worth the dependability of this baby. I’ve bought it at least 5 times so I would know!

1.3.2017

I love this eyeliner, by far the quickest and easiest eyeliner to apply in my opinion, the fine pen tip is soft but firm making your eyeliner comfortable and easy to apply. I have been wearing winged eyeliner for over a decade by now so maybe I do just find it easier but in my opinion it's less messy than liquid and dries quicker and is easier to work with than gel eyeliner. Unlike most pen eyeliners this is dark black and consistent, doesn't run out or become patchy, I've been using it for a couple months and it's yet to dry out, it's my new every day eyeliner I love it.

15.5.2019

I've tried and tested a range of eyeliners of all different prices and brands, and this is by far the best. You can put it on with ease, enjoying putting it on, wipe away any mistakes easily whilst it's wet, but once it has set, you are good to go for 48 hours without it moving. (I had it on then ended up in hospital, was worried I'd look like a panda, but it stayed immaculate the whole time). If you have watery eyes you'd still get a whole day out it.Absolutely worth the money for the quality and time you get out of it (4 months roughly of daily use).My favourite.

31.1.2017

Will definately buy this again.I have used all eyeliners that are supposed to last all day.This is buy far the best,the only one that claim close was Smashbox,down side with Smashboc,it didn't last long..So easy to use and you make a thin line or thick line.Delivery was really fast to.I reviewed lots of eyeli ers as I have small eyes,and I was fed up having to check my mirror ,incase I looked like a panda!!.This one,i dont have to woery. I stll have one in December,so this was a new one as it was runnng low.You need to shakeit to exract te lgd withn the pen.

3.3.2017

First liquid liner I have ever used. It is nice and easy to use with a nice thin tip. Smudge-proof and stays on all day like it says it does. The only issue I have with it is it slightly gets rubbed off when I use my eyelash curler, sometimes a bit comes off with it. But Im not sure if thats because I haven't waited long enough for it to dry, mornings are too hectic! Been drenched in the rain and also stays fine.I love this product and probably won't ever look at another brand. Just stick to what you know is good.

19.12.2018

Makes all my other ones look like crap, what the hell was I doing before this was in my life walking around like some sort of smudge monster. If I'm wearing primer or foundation, it will literally stay in place for 24hrs of partying. Yes, I found this out this out through first hand experience. I've always used coconut or argan oil to gently remove eye make up (I also use waterproof mascara) and that works well to remove this. It's easy to apply and has great definition, don't waste your time with other eyeliners.

List All Products

Terms and ConditionsPrivacy Policy